EWN Elections 2026

Johannesburg could face five more years of poor governance under coalition deal, warns expert

Johannesburg could face another five years of poor governance if coalition parties prioritise political deals over service delivery, Wits governance expert Professor Alex van den Heever warns.

Kabous Le Roux

 Johannesburg's future hangs in the balance as coalition negotiations continue, with governance expert Professor Alex van den Heever warning that political deals could leave the city facing another five years of corruption and poor service delivery. (Picture credit: kellyermis/123rf)

Johannesburg's future hangs in the balance as coalition negotiations continue, with governance expert Professor Alex van den Heever warning that political deals could leave the city facing another five years of corruption and poor service delivery. (Picture credit: kellyermis/123rf)

kellyermis/123rf

Johannesburg residents could be left facing another five years of poor governance if the parties negotiating to take control of the city prioritise political interests over service delivery, a governance expert has warned.

Professor Alex van den Heever, from the Wits School of Governance, says the composition of the coalition and, crucially, what holds its members together will determine whether the city gets an administration capable of addressing its problems.

Speaking to 702's John Perlman, Van den Heever warned that coalitions built around political transactions rather than a shared commitment to governing could result in fragmented service delivery and widespread corruption.

His comments come amid ongoing negotiations over the future of Johannesburg following the local government elections, with reports suggesting the ANC is close to reaching an agreement with ActionSA.

The two parties together have 106 seats in the 270-seat council, well short of the 136 needed for a majority.

Bringing in the EFF and MK Party would give them a majority, but Van den Heever questioned what such an arrangement would mean for the city's governance.

Related articles:

—DA refuses to drop Helen Zille as ActionSA edges closer to ANC coalition deal

—Coalition talks reach critical stage as ActionSA weighs ANC and DA offers

Coalition deals could create opportunities for corruption

Van den Heever said the central question was what would hold the parties together and what concessions would be made to secure their support.

"The real question is, what is the glue that keeps the particular coalition together? What are the quid pro quos? And how does it affect how they actually govern at the end of the day?" he said.

He warned that coalitions based purely on political transactions could effectively hand portions of the city over to individual parties.

"If they are purely transactional... effectively you hand portions of the city over to party political control rather than an overall governing approach. And it potentially fragments delivery and potentially results in lots and lots of corruption."

Van den Heever questioned whether the parties involved would be united by a genuine commitment to improving Johannesburg or by opportunities to access municipal resources.

He argued that political consensus was not necessarily a positive development if it was built around the wrong incentives.

"Basically, condoning corrupt conduct is not actually an ideological position of any worth. It is essentially a privatisation of a public authority," Van den Heever said.

He said municipal coalitions should instead compete on their ability to deliver basic services, including roads, electricity, housing and property regulation.

Residents could be stuck with a dysfunctional coalition for five years

Van den Heever also raised concerns about the consequences of South Africa's electoral and governance arrangements, arguing that residents have limited recourse once coalition agreements have been concluded.

He said the bargaining process following an election could leave voters stuck with the resulting administration for the next five years.

"The problem with our electoral process is that essentially once the bargaining kicks in after an election, you're pretty much stuck with that for five years," he said.

If governance structures were too weak to hold political parties accountable for corruption, residents could face a prolonged period of poor administration.

"And that's a very long time for a city to be run in that particular way," he warned.

ActionSA's role in a possible ANC-led coalition questioned

Perlman asked whether ActionSA could provide a sufficiently strong governance influence in a coalition involving the ANC and other parties.

Van den Heever questioned how much influence the party would actually have, particularly if it was prepared to make substantial concessions to secure an agreement that excluded the DA.

He also raised questions about ActionSA's own governance record, pointing to concerns surrounding Tshwane, including the collapse of water systems and questions about water tanker contracts.

Van den Heever said the party still had much to demonstrate before its participation in a coalition could be regarded as a guarantee of better governance.

He questioned why ActionSA was so opposed to a straightforward agreement with the DA, suggesting that the reasons behind that position deserved scrutiny.

Van den Heever said the parties' commitment to governing would ultimately become clear once the coalitions had been established.

"But unfortunately, we might find out in a very nasty way," he said.

Original EWN source reporting